Opinions, Context & Ideas from the TPM Editors TPM Editor's Blog

Alexander Lays Down the Nonsense

Back in 2005, the Republicans threatened to abolish the filibuster to allow votes on judicial nominees. There are lots of Democrats who would like that to happen right now. But it's not. The Democrats are proposing to use the existing senate rules that disallow filibusters on bills with certain tightly-defined kinds of budgetary impact. These aren't kind of like the same thing. They're completely different.

Not only are these totally standard rules of the senate. But they're ones that Republicans themselves repeatedly used during their majority years earlier in the decade. Indeed, the Democrats are still hamstringing themselves to a great degree since the "reconciliation" process only disallows filibusters for very specific kinds of legislation.

Sen. Alexander can say whatever he wants. They need an argument. And they're about out of them. But this one is so vacant and baseless that I'd hate to see reporters falling for it. If you see that happening, please send me examples at our comments email address.