I was away for

Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

I was away for the weekend and had only occasional web access. So I was happy to see when I got in this evening that there was an inevitable follow-up to Friday evening’s post about Sen. Evan Bayh’s (D) appearance on the Stephanopoulos show. We asked, you’ll remember, whether George would pop the question that would get Sen. Bayh out of the Fainthearted Faction.

And, as it turns out, Stephanopoulos is something of a master at the highly-specialized art of Faction extraction. He put the question to Bayh in terms he couldn’t duck or talk around. And to Bayh’s great credit, he didn’t even try. George got not only a clear answer, but a good one.

Here’s the relevant passage …

STEPHANOPOULOS: OK. Let’s turn, then, to the president’s agenda. In his State of the Union address Wednesday, of course the focus is going to be Iraq and Social Security reform.

And a lot of Democrats are wondering where you stand on Social Security reform. You’ve supported President Bush on his tax cuts. Let me ask you about these Social Security reform proposals, and there are three answers that could be: yes and no (ph).

Number one, would you support diverting the payroll tax into individual accounts?

BAYH: No, I would not, George.

And, look, the president is probably going to talk a lot about ownership and individual choice. I think those are great concepts, and I can support those — but in addition to the current Social Security system, not as a replacement for it.

Look, you may own your home; a lot of Americans do. I bet you have insurance. Ownership and insurance have to go hand in hand.

Social Security is the insurance. Senior citizens in our country can always rely on it to make sure they’re not desperately poor in their old age.

Should we have ownership and choice in addition to that? Yes, we should. But we should never do anything to undermine that insurance. That is one of the bedrock principles of our country.

There was some further discussion of Social Security between the two men. One point Bayh raised was the possibility of a form of ‘means testing’ at the very high-end of the income scale, though it was framed around the question of whether benefits are indexed to wages or inflation. In any case, the whole exchange pointed clearly to the fact that Bayh just handed in his membership card in the Fainthearted Faction.

See the new updated Faction list here.

Latest Editors' Blog
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: