In it, but not of it. TPM DC

Patty Murray: The One Percent Aren't 'Job Creators'

Newscom / Bill Clark

"Republicans seem to be operating under the backwards economic principle that only tax cuts for the richest Americans and biggest corporations are worth fighting for," the remarks read. "In fact, they have a name for this group of people: they call them 'job creators.' They believe the only ones who create jobs in America are the rich--and they claim that the tax cuts and loopholes they fight for that benefit the wealthy will somehow trickle down to ordinary families. Mr. President--we know this is wrong. We know this Republican economic policy has failed us. It was this kind of thinking that turned a surplus in into a deficit, that brought the economy to its knees, that failed the middle class--and that allowed the wealthiest Americans to amass record fortunes paying the lowest tax rates in decades."

Murray cites one of her own constituents -- billionaire tech company founder and venture capitalist Nick Hanauer -- who turned a lot of heads when he made this argument in a Bloomberg op-ed last week.

The GOP's definition of a "job creator" has become conventional wisdom, in part because Democrats haven't really contested it. Murray's remarks suggest that Dems, bolstered by a heightened national focus on the economy, taxes, and income inequality, will be taking this notion head on.

About The Author


Brian Beutler is TPM's senior congressional reporter. Since 2009, he's led coverage of health care reform, Wall Street reform, taxes, the GOP budget, the government shutdown fight and the debt limit fight. He can be reached at