In it, but not of it. TPM DC

Oh Canada, We Stand On Guard For Political Upheaval


In addition, both Liberal leader Michael Ignatieff and Bloc leader Gilles Duceppe lost their seats in Parliament -- Ignatieff losing by five points to a Conservative, and Duceppe losing by 11 points to the NDP candidate. Duceppe resigned as Bloc leader on Monday night, and Ignatieff -- who initially said he would stay on as long as the party wanted him -- announced on Tuesday that he is quitting as Liberal head.

One might be quick to suspect that the NDP and Liberals split the anti-Harper vote, delivering a lot of districts into the Conservative column. But in fact, a review of the districts themselves shows that this happened in surprisingly few cases -- perhaps enough to just put Harper over the majority line, but maybe not. The Conservatives won most of their districts with outright majorities or very strong pluralities, and with the Liberals reduced to being a marginalized middle party it is unclear whether the NDP could have achieved a majority with the support of a large enough portion of Liberal voters.

So how did things go so wrong for the Liberals? They have had losses before, including some very bad ones. But throughout the past century -- as TPM noted in a guide to the election -- they were very much the institutional party of government, only rarely losing to the Conservatives after blunders had piled up, and then returning to office after a few years of cleaning up their act. This time, it appears that they deeply misjudged the political needs of the moment, and created an enormous opening for the NDP to overtake them.

Starting back in the 1960s, the traditionally centrist Liberals shifted leftward and co-opted many of the NDP's issues, first under Prime Minister Lester Pearson, and then especially so under the long-serving Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau (who had previously been an activist with the NDP's radical socialist predecessor, the Co-Operative Commonwealth Federation, and had only been a member of the Liberals for three years when he was elevated to the top job). After a big defeat in 1984, the Liberals shifted back to the middle in the 1990s, with fiscal austerity and pro-business policies under Prime Minister Jean Chretien.

But then in the last few years, when it was again clearly necessary to shift leftward and impress progressive voters, the party instead picked the decidedly centrist Ignatieff as leader, sealing their fate to be squeezed out between the right and left.