In it, but not of it. TPM DC

Associated Press Ignores Obama On Drawing False Equivalences On Health Care

Qxpqbt0dakqx0s4izlx2
Newscom

"[I]f Republicans have moved to the right on health care, it's also true that Obama has moved to the left," reads an AP wrap on the Obama speech. "He strenuously opposed a mandate forcing people to obtain health insurance until he won office and changed his mind."

It's true that Obama campaigned against an individual mandate in 2008, only to embrace it -- however reluctantly -- after he became president. But to say that constitutes a move to the left betrays a lack of understanding about the origins and purpose of the individual mandate, and of Obama's broader evolution on health care reform.

In the early aughts, as a member of the Illinois state Senate, Obama strongly supported a single-payer health care system.

Over the years, that position became more tempered by political realities, and by the 2008 Democratic primary, he had embraced the basic framework of what eventually became "Obamacare," with two glaring exceptions: He supported a public option, and he opposed an individual mandate -- the latter of which was crucial to the success of "Romneycare" in Massachusetts.

Obama was criticized by a mix of liberal and conservative technocrats and industry stakeholders for opposing the mandate. By embracing it as president, while dropping the public option, he was arguably moving further right still from his past support for single-payer. As Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-IA) -- then the top Republican on the committee that drafted the health care law -- said before health care reform turned toxic on the right, "I believe that there is a bipartisan consensus to have individual mandates."

As Obama lurched toward Massachusetts' plan as a potential framework for bipartisan consensus, Republicans quickly abandoned the pretense of supporting the principle of universal health care of any kind.