In it, but not of it. TPM DC

Americans United Launches Radio Ad Against Bachmann's 'Wean' Comments About Social Security (AUDIO)


Woman: Did you hear what that Michele Bachmann said this time?

Man: No, what was it?

Woman: Congresswoman Bachmann actually said we should be "weaned" off our Social Security and Medicare. She wants to privatize Social Security and replaced Medicare with some kind of voucher system that won't even cover the full cost of medical care or prescriptions.

Man: So let me get this straight. Congresswoman Bachmann wants me to gamble with my Social Security on Wall Street?

Woman: Yup, she wants us to hand over our Social Security to the same greedy reckless CEOs responsible for crashing our economy. That's just plain crazy.

Man: No thanks. Privatization was a bad idea when President Bush tried it, and it's even worse today.

Woman: And Congresswoman Bachmann actually wants me to trade in my Medicare for some voucher that's not worth the paper it's printed on. She should spend less time on national TV, and more time worrying about senior citizens back home in Minnesota.

Man: Let's call Congresswoman Bachmann right now at 320-253-5931 and tell her, 'Hands off my Social Security and Medicare."

Woman: Paid for by Americans United For Change.

Late Update: Americans United's communications director Jeremy Funk gives us this comment:

Star Trib: "Bachmann's spokester Dave Dziok cites a potential fix based on a proposal by Rep. Paul Ryan, R-Wis., which resembles a reheated version of Bush's personal retirement accounts."

She supports Ryan's proposal that would carve into the Social Security trust fund and push tomorrow's retirees towards risky private accounts - what he proposes may be voluntary at first, but let's not forget that this would mean massive benefit cuts across the board for people left in the system that don't choose to go the retirement account route.

The script is accurate. Bachmann does very much "want" the working husband and wife in the ad to gamble their Social Security on Wall Street when they hit retirement age. Sure it would be voluntary at first, and very risky to those who do - and very costly to the people left in the system.