« O'Reilly amazed by civility in Harlem restaurant | Talking Points Memo Home | Oh, that Jena Six »

'Nutpicking' hits the big time

09.22.07 -- 11:34AM
By Steve Benen

For quite a while, conservatives have embraced an annoying strategy -- trawl through liberal comments sections in the hopes of finding intemperate remarks. The right then takes these comments to "prove" that the left is made up of unhinged radicals.

The practice has always been rather self-defeating. In fact, about a year ago, Kevin Drum came up with a sensible maxim: "If you're forced to rely on random blog commenters to make a point about the prevalence of some form or another of disagreeable behavior, you've pretty much made exactly the opposite point." Eventually, the practice was even given a name: "Nutpicking."

Unfortunately, the practice seems to have spread. Instead of far-right blogs trolling through liberal comment sections for fodder, now Republican candidates for public office are doing it.

A Republican state legislator from Fairfax County has launched an attack ad on cable TV against his Democratic opponent that features unidentified, unverified quotes from a blog.

The ad by Del. Timothy D. Hugo points to a new form of negative campaigning in which information for an attack ad is sourced to comments posted on the Internet instead of more authoritative sources such as news reports or public records.

Hugo's ad highlights critical comments about his Democratic opponent, Rex Simmons, that someone with the screen name "Pitin" posted on the Democratic blog Raising Kaine.

This is obviously absurd. The TV ad claims to alert the public to what "others are saying" about Simmons, and quotes criticism of the Democrat's campaign from Raising Kaine, before concluding, "We just can't trust Rex Simmons."

Actually, we just can't trust campaign commercials that rely on pseudonymous criticism from a blog's comment section. In this case, there's obviously nothing to stop the Hugo campaign from going to Raising Kane, leaving derogatory comments about Simmons, and then using their own planted denigrations in their own campaign commercials.

Nutpicking was irritating enough when it was confined to conservative blogs. Taking it onto the air is not a positive development.

Recent Archives

June 29, 2008 - July 5, 2008
June 22, 2008 - June 28, 2008
June 15, 2008 - June 21, 2008
June 8, 2008 - June 14, 2008

TPM News Headlines




Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address